3648 Lincolnway E
Massillon, OH 44646
(330) 478-3800

"Finally your wallet & taste buds agree"

331 West High Street
Orrville, OH 44667
(330) 684-2000

Home   |   Menu   |   Maps   |   Photos   |   Coupons   |   Games   |   Testimonials   |   Contact   |   Order Now!

Lincoln Way Pizza Menu:

Daily Specials:

Monday: Any gyro $2.75.
Tuesday: King Size Sub $5.50
Wednesday: Chicken 4 pc. mixed $5.00
Thursday: Large 1 Item Pizza $5.99.
Sunday: Medium Specialty or 3 Topping $5.99.

Pick 2: Any Two Items below PLUS Breadsticks. $15.99

Pick 3: Any Three Items below PLUS a side. $21.99

Items: Large 1 Topping Pizza, Medium Specialty Pizza, King Size Sub, 10 Jumbo Wings, 2 Gyros, 1/2 Bucket of Ribs or 4 Piece Chicken.


Medium: Cheese- $5.99. Extra topping- $0.99. Specialty- $7.99.
Large: Cheese- $6.99. Topping- $1.59. Specialty- $12.99.
Thin Crust available upon request.

Toppings available: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion, Green Pepper, Bacon, Ham, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Jalapeno Peppers, Pineapples, Ground Beef, Green Olives, Anchovies.

Specialty Pizzas:
Pep-Pep-Pepperoni: edge to edge pepperoni.
Supreme: Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper.
Carnivore: Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon.
Herbivore: Mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper.
Taco: Salsa, cheddar cheese, taco meat, creole seasonings with sour cream.
Hawaiian: Ham, bacon, pineapple.
Fiesta Chicken: grilled chicken, sausage, banana peppers, Creole seasonings with sour cream.
BBQ Chicken: Chicken, pineapples, bacon with BBQ sauce.
Buffalo: Buffalo Sauce, grilled chicken, cheddar cheese, blue cheese on side.
Philly Steak: Steak, onions, mushroom, with a garlic sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch: Ranch Sauce with chicken and bacon.


Medium: $8.99.
Large $12.99
Original: Ham, Salami, & Pepperoni
3 Topping: Choose your favorite toppings or choose Philly Steak, Pep-Pep, Carnivore, Herbivore, or Supreme! (Just like our pizzas)!


We also carry boneless wings!
10 Wings: $7.99
20 Wings: $13.99
The Tailgater (40): $25.99
Sauces: (most mild to hottest)
Teriyaki, Honey Mustard, Garlic Parmesan, Garlic, BBQ, Mild, Spicy Ranch, Spicy Garlic Parmesan, Hot, Cajun, Spicy BBQ, Hellfire (at your own risk).


4PC MIXED: $6.99 4PC DARK: $6.79 4PC WHITE: $7.99
8PC MIXED: $12.99 8PC DARK: $12.49 8PC WHITE: $14.99
12PC MIXED: $17.49 12PC DARK: $15.49 12PC WHITE: $20.49
20PC MIXED: $25.49 20PC DARK: $21.49 20PC: $30.49


All $5.99 (Except for Ultimate Philly)
Ultimate Philly: $7.99
Philly Steak: $6.79
Philly Chicken: $6.79
Italian: $6.79
Meatball: $6.79
Ham and Cheese: $6.79
BLT: $6.79
Pizza: $6.79
Chicken Club : $6.79


Half Bucket: $7.49
Full Bucket: $13.99
The Tailgater (3 Full Buckets): $35.99
All Topped With Our Award Winning BBQ Sauce!


Served with Lettuce, Romano, & Onions, and a side of Cucumber Sauce.
Also choose your meat: Original, Chicken, Crispy Chicken, or Steak.
2 Pack: $6.99 3 Pack: $9.99 6 Pack: $17.99
Signature Gyros: $3.99
Spicy Gyros: A hotter version of the original..
Cajun Gyro Topped with Cajun seasoning.
Chicken Bacon Ranch: grilled or crispy chicken with bacon and a side of ranch.
Philly Gyro: with mushroom, onions, & provolone.
Double Meat Gyro: $4.49


Rigatoni with meat sauce &meatballs or baked ziti.
Individual: $5.99 Family: $11.99


Chef Salad
Blackened Chicken
Gyro Salad
Crispy Chicken


$2.99 (Double Order $5.00)
Potato Wedges, Mozzarella Sticks, Breadsticks, Chicken Tenders, Side Salad, Garlic Cheese Bread, 2 Liter of Pop $2.00 plus tax
Extra Sauces: $0.50.

Home   |   Menu   |   Directions  |   Photos  |   Coupons  |   Pizza Challenge!  |   Games  |   Testimonials  |   Order  |   Contact Us

Thanks for visiting Lincoln Way Pizza Shop.com - Website design by Ohio Web Design.

Copyright 2012

Pizza Challenge
Are you ready
to take the
Get started now!
Monthly Specials

Monthly Special
Any Large Pizza

          Up To 5 toppings